Skip to content

More on Jahi McMath

January 9, 2014

Hi Reader.

The macabre spectacle that is the case of Jahi McMath just keeps getting ridiculouser and ridiculouser. I wrote a summary of the story yesterday, but for a Twitter version, it can be summarized thusly: Jahi is dead. Tragic. Those involved with poking, prodding corpse should be shunned as they prevent family from grieving.

Today, there is additional information about the case, which is getting more vile by the second. Yesterday, I read an interesting article about Christopher Dolan, the attorney for Jahi’s family, and felt a soupçon of understanding for his position in working for the family. This feeling was utterly nuked today when he opened his yap again and stated that Jahi is”improving” now that she is “getting the treatment she should have gotten 28 days ago”.

First, there is NO “treatment” for death. Dolan seems to be slithering right by that understanding, which is hardly surprising since, by his own admission, he knows absolutely nothing about brain death. Second, to state that a deceased person is “improving” is quite possibly the most ignorant thing that has ever been said in the Annals of Ignorance–and as you know, Reader, we see quite a bit of it in the world of anti-vaxxers. Dolan may think that he is advocating for the family, but what he is actually doing is apparently confusing large numbers of people, who do not understand that Jahi is dead. Further, Dolan is executing an even crueler trick. He is preventing a family that needs to properly grieve for a child from doing so.

I have heard people who have lost loved ones wish that they could fast-forward a year, so that they could reach a time when the pain would not be so horribly acute. If Jahi’s family had been able to accept her death, and were not encouraged to perpetuate this circus, then they would already be nearly a month past the death of a child. I am not at all implying that they will ever get over her death–they will not. But a month of grieving is still a month when the healing, however slowly, could have begun.

Those involved in encouraging this magical thinking are nothing short of vermin. And while Dolan claims that he will not be involved an any potential lawsuits against the hospital should they be filed, he sure appears to be trying to set it up for a buddy.

From → Uncategorized

  1. One question that this case has brought up for me is whether a diagnosis of brain death can be mistaken? I am NOT suggesting that the diagnosis is mistaken in Jahi’s case – clearly with all the public attention the medical people will have re-checked and re-checked in this case – but it seems that in a more general sense a false positive diagnosis must occasionally occur in the same way that catastrophic medical mistakes of other types are occasionally made. Every so often human fallibility plus the weight of numbers leads to incredibly awful mistakes being made – I’m thinking mistakes in the one-in-a-million category like a surgeon accidentally removing the one functioning lung from a man with lung cancer who was scheduled to have the diseased side amputated.

    When I google likely strings (“mistaken diagnosis of brain death”, etc.) it *seems* that there are many results. Are these results mistaken in the same way that googling “do vaccines cause autism?” will get you falsehoods, or is something else going on? I’d like to see a decent article which went into all the issues – cases like Zach Dunlap make people understandably nervous. When Steve Novella wrote it up he added: “It should also be noted that this case is a rare anomaly. The criteria for brain death are very conservative, and if properly employed there is almost no chance (I am tempted not even to say “almost”) of error or of meaningful recovery following a diagnosis of brain death.” which sounds very sensible but as a layperson I don’t know how to tell what the criteria are or how I determine whether somebody is “properly employing” them.

    If I ever find myself in the situation of being told a loved one is brain dead, is there any way that I – as a lay person – could usefully evaluate whether things have been done “properly” or do I have to cross my fingers and hope? I recognise that the likelihood of somebody being mistakenly declared brain dead are extremely extremely extremely low, but the consequences of misdiagnosis in this situation are pretty much as high as they can ever be, so I don’t think it’s irrational to want to feel that we can somehow reassure ourselves no mistakes have been made.

    • I think this is a fair question. My first thought is that you have carefully and rationally laid out all of the reasons that the odds of a mistaken diagnosis of brain death are extremely low, to the point that it approaches zero. It is entirely possible, as you point out, that googling this is very analogous to finding sites that claim that vaccines cause autism. “Brain-dead” has entered the lexicon of most people by now and as such is thrown around very casually, with very little understanding of what it actually means. Regarding the alleged cases of people with “brain death” who “recover”, I am extremely skeptical of their claims. I would put the odds at one in a billion of it happening, and the odds of it happening to you are basically zero. Whether or not there is blood flow to or electrical activity in the brain is really not a gray area.

      However, to address your questions, if you were ever concerned or had doubts about any diagnosis a loved one received, my advice would always be to seek a second opinion from a completely independent source. I would also recommend that if you were ever in a situation similar to the family of Jahi that you consider the power of emotion in decision-making, and if the second opinion is not what you wanted to hear, you still must be open to accepting it. It would be a tremendously difficult situation, but the fact is that the family is essentially torturing themselves. Much like the logic-resistant position of anti-vaxxers, they believe that she might wake up, and as such no amount of science will persuade them otherwise. It’s truly a tragedy all around.

      • Upon further reflection you are right about the emotion thing – the psychological effect of feeling guilt that you might not have “done enough” is tremendous. I think getting a second opinion if concerned is a good idea here, even if only for the psychological reassurance value of calming oneself. Thanks for letting me muse on this :)

  2. For instance, you may be doing step ups with curls utilising the yellow resistance bands that are coloring.

  3. The specific amount of nutrients your dog may get especially is dependent upon what form and the quantity of product while in the brand you
    are currently eating your dog.

  4. Good for many who undergo from insomnia, who have trouble getting to sleep or who need
    more rest in sleeping.

  5. The thing is that young ladies like to wear something smooth, fresh, and not too sweet – MEXX woman or
    Jil Sanders PURE line is also a great advantage. 5 cm
    (1 in) long with five acute lobes, 10-13 mm diameter when open at night; they are produced in cymose
    inflorescences, and are strongly scented.
    The traditional clothing from Israel resurrects traditions going
    back 3,000 years.

  6. Most of these features will improve you gaming experience,
    while some may give you the capability to perform other tasks such
    as downloading game demos, movies, and music. You set up a camera, and it detects it, you set it,
    and then synchronize the two together, to get harmony between them.

    Just make sure that you own the original copy and
    will not sell or give away the backup copies to anyone in any
    way possible because this is an act of piracy.

  7. I am really happy to read this blog posts which carries plenty of helpful
    information, thanks for providing these statistics.

  8. If you are looking for different sized feet,different sized shoes,polio survivors group,diabetes foot
    problems,foot length difference,mismatched footwear. You will also
    be able to choose custom Pokeballs, like fast balls, lure balls,
    timer balls, or the legendary master ball.
    Simple tie dying instructions can found easily on the web or even by visiting your local library.

  9. I really ove your site.. Excellent colors & theme.
    Did you create this site yourself? Please reply bacdk as I’m planning to create my own personl website and would love
    to learn where youu got this from orr what the theme is named.

  10. Although the title doesn’t appear around the page itself,
    search engines like google consider it an accurate description of your site.
    ‘ It is very important to have a very clear concise website that features easy reading
    content, easy navigation, along with a clean well engineered design. By crawling
    the world wide web, we imply it sends requests to all or any the servers hosting web sites,
    downloads copies of these, after which sends them off on the Indexer for processing.
    In some instances, people assume that they could possibly get a tremendous benefit from
    your search engines like yahoo in an expedient amount
    of time.

  11. Thanks , I’ve recently been looking for information approximately this subject for a while and yours
    is the best I’ve found out till now. However, what
    about the bottom line? Are you sure concerning the supply?

  12. Founder and Editor-in-Chief Sade Awe options the weddings and recommendation of vendors from around the world, so whether or not you’re having your dream wedding in Dallas or
    Dubai you are sure to seek out resources and concepts to help carry your large day
    vision to life.

  13. The following websites are free and list rental properties and homes on the market.
    Now that I’ve told you tips on how to find apartments with out paying
    for internet-based assist in your search I do wish to relate one thing I heard from an condo proprietor.
    That is one hell of a complicated house searching experience.

  14. On the coronary heart of the 2014 YZF-R1 is its 998cc inline four cylinder engine
    using Yamaha’s cross-plane expertise giving the engine an uneven firing order, for the smoothest energy delivery accessible, and that very distinctive sound you simply do not get with any other inline 4 motor.

  15. We overview investment returns on a risk-adjusted foundation, taking into consideration geopolitical, macroeconomic and real estate
    components which are particular to every opportunity.
    Real property investment requires experience and shrewd judgment –
    precisely the mix we are able to provide.

  16. Throughout a college summer time break I read an ad
    from a stitching machine retailer that marketed a terrific
    deal on a used machine.

  17. A veterinarian will stain the eye with a dye to search
    for corneal scratches.

  18. Your style is unique compared to other folks I have read stuff from.

    I appreciate you for posting when you’ve got the opportunity, Guess I’ll just book mark this web site.

  19. To grow to be one, full a further 180 hours finding out real estate
    brokerage, together with courses in appraisal, actual property finance
    and real estate law, in addition to two further courses
    in subjects of your choice, resembling contract regulation, economics, property administration or other subjects authorised
    by the Actual Property Board.

  20. Verify when your employer gives free bus tickets as a benefit.

  21. This innovation was co-developed by Well being Resources and Providers Administration,
    the Centers for Illness Control and Prevention, and Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Companies.

  22. I used to sing josh groban songs and musicals.

  23. I was shopping online and came throughout and was wondering if anyone
    right here had ever tried ordering customized tailored stuff online.

    I’ve been doing this for my shirts for some time.

  24. Baby cuddlers are the people who find themselves specifically skilled in holding the infants and cuddling them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 335 other followers

%d bloggers like this: